Criminal Law And Violence In Sports

Criminal Law And Violence In Sports

In 2004, then-Vancouver Canucks power forward Todd Bertuzzi made headlines when he punched Colorado Avalanche center Steve Moore in the back of the head during a Vancouver-Colorado hockey game. Following these events, Bertuzzi was charged with assault causing bodily harm. In December 2004, Bertuzzi plead guilty and was given a conditional sentence with one year of probation.

During and after the Bertuzzi incident, the issue of violence during sporting events, both at the professional and amateur level, received a lot of media attention. Criminal defence lawyers, judges, and other legal professionals have developed ways to differentiate between violent acts that are "part of the game" and violent acts that are criminal in nature. This issue comes up most often in hockey, rugby, football, wrestling, boxing, marshal arts and other full contact sports. Obviously, these sports often involve physical acts that lead to injury (such as checking, tackling, fighting, etc.). However, not all of these physical acts are criminal in nature.

Under the Criminal Code, a person commits assault when he or she intentionally applies force to another person without that person's consent. In essence, every time you touch another person, you "intentionally apply force" to that person. But, obviously, the law would be absurd if it categorized every touch as an assault. The consent requirement in the second half of the provision means that the law only catches unwanted touching. Thus, the first important issue in determining whether an incident of touching constitutes an assault, is determining whether the complainant consented to the touching in question. Consent can be either expressed or implied. Naturally, you do not have to obtain the verbal consent of your close friends and family members every time you touch them the nature of your relationship implies that some types of touching are welcome. However, it is prudent to ask a stranger permission before touching them for any reason.

The second issue we must consider is the scope of that consent, so that we can determine whether the complainant consented to the type of touching in question. For example, though your relationship with your family may imply that certain types of touching are non-objectionable, it does not constitute consent to sexual or violent touching. In fact, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that, for legal purposes, a person can never consent to violent touching which causes bodily harm.

There is an exception to the rule that you cannot consent to violent touching that allows individuals to consent to violence if that violence is part of a socially useful activity. The Supreme Court has indicated that, under this exception, individuals can consent to violent activity that normally occurs in the course of a sporting event.

In the context of a sporting event, a player implies that he or she consents to certain types of touching simply by participating in the game. That consent may apply to some forms of violent touching that normally occur in the context of a sporting event; however, that does not mean that players consent to all forms of violence. The Bertuzzi case provides a good example of how challenging this dilemma can be. By participating in the hockey game, Steve Moore implied that he consented to be touched in a variety of violent ways. But it is difficult to determine what specific acts he consented to. Hockey often involves checking, hitting from behind, "spearing", "butt-ending", slashing, high-sticking and fighting. Though many of these acts are against the rules of the game, hockey players are not charged with assault every time they engage in violent touching that result in a penalty. Thus, the scope of violent acts hockey players consent to must go beyond just those acts which are allowed by the rules of the game. So, the question becomes, what was different about the hit by Bertuzzi to make the Attorney General charge him with assault?

In the game between Vancouver and Colarado preceding the game in which Bertuzzi hit Moore, Moore had injured the Canuck's captain Markus Naslund. During the game, it seemed that several Vancouver players were trying to get back at Moore for injuring Naslund. Moreover, before the hit, Bertuzzi was following Moore around the ice trying to provoke him into fighting. When Bertuzzi finally hit Moore it was completely unprovoked and from behind. It was clear that Bertuzzi's hit had nothing to do with the hockey game and was instead motivated by revenge. Moreover, the hit to the back of Moore's head seemed especially violent. Bertuzzi grabbed Moore's jersey from behind and punched him. He then fell on top of him. The injuries Moore suffered were substantial and forced him into an early retirement. This is why it attracted the attention of the criminal justice system.

However, assaults that occur during sporting events are not always as clear as in the Bertuzzi example. For that reason, in R. v. Cey the Supreme Court set out a test for determining the scope of consent to violence in the context of a sporting event. The court explained that the scope of implied consent must be assessed objectively based on the normal and reasonable expectations of fair play. The court will consider several factors, including:

* The setting of the game

* The nature of the league (are the players amateurs or professionals?)

* The age of the players

* The conditions of the game (are the players wearing protective equipment? Is the sport one that normally includes violence such as hockey, boxing, wrestling, or marshal arts?)

* The degree of the risk of injury (is this a sport where injuries are common and players can be assumed to have accepted the risk of injury, such as hockey, football or boxing?)

* The probability of serious harm (is this a sport where participants can be assumed to have accepted the risk of being seriously hurt, such as professional football or professional boxing?).Kostman Pyzer is a criminal defence law firm serving clients in the Greater Toronto area and elsewhere in the province of Ontario since 1983. Not every Toronto lawyer is created equal. We are creative, experienced and hardworking. We pride ourselves on our aggressive representation of clients and our relentless commitment to success. Visit online today.

10 Winning Ways To Play Football Manager Rpgs Onli19 Basketball Quotes For March Madness
3 Deadly Hardcore Training Thatll Make You Jump Hi3 Sports To Keep You Fit
30 Coaching Dos And Donts To Motivate Your Basketb4 Adrenaline Pumping Water Sports In Maldives
4x4 The New Sports Car5 Key Skills Needed To Become A Professional Baske
5 Key Things You Need To Know About Extreme Sports55 Basketball Player Uses These Techniques To Lear
A Football Themed WeddingA Guide To Live Football Online
A Short History Of BasketballAbout
Adding Sports To The Purview Of ErgonomicsAdidas Skateboarding Shoes For Skating Sports
Adidas Sports Shoes Clover Stands For Pray Hope AnAllowance Of Purchasing Genuine Set Of Soccer Jers
Anticipation Building For The New Football ShirtsAspiring Soccer Stars Head To Italy For Trials
Aston Villa Legends Profiles Of The Greatest PlayeAthenas Attic I Complete Collection Of Sports Gear
Basketball AccessoriesBasketball Basics Shooting
Basketball Coaching How To Beat A ZoneBasketball Court Resurfacing
Basketball Drills To Improve Lay UpsBasketball Games Online Tips On How To Become A Be
Basketball Uniforms And Colour ChoiceBecoming A Sports Agent
Before You Buy Magnetic Sports Bracelets Learn AboBest Selling Mlb Sports Jerseys
Both Men And Women Are Crazy For The Game Of FootbBritains Little Sports Car That Could The Tvr
Buy Football Merchandise Online At Affordable PricCasual Fashion With Sports Jerseys
Cheap Soccer Uniforms Low Price For Quality StuffChelsea Football Player Frank Lampard Fact File
Choosing The Right Football Boots For Performance College Football Helmet Decals Show Your Support W
Completely Different Original Nba Basketball JerseCreate Your Own Custom Football Jerseys
Criminal Law And Violence In SportsDavies Sports Best Selling Cricket Equipment
Design Your Own Adidas Football BootsDesigner Nike Shoesexcellent Sports Footwear In Th
Diego Maradona Puma Soccer BootsDo Sports Necklaces Work
Download Wii Sports Resort Nintendo Wii GameDunlop From Rubber Tires To Dunlop Bags Sports Act
Eight Things You Should Know About Leather FootbalEnjoy The Sports With Wraparound Prescription Sung
Essential Notes And Points When Buying Sports FootEuropean Basketball Salaries
European Sports Car The Best In High PerformanceFamous Football Fathers And Sons
Five Tips About Football BootsFootball And Its Fans
Football Boots Article Soccer Boots Diego MaradonaFootball Recruiting Letter Four Keys To A Great Le
Football ReligionFootball Scouting
Football Shirts That Speak Your MindFootball Shoe Technology That Betters Your Perfoma
Football Square How To Play InstructionsFootball Training Tips
Forster Has Everything For Fresh Water Or Salt WatFree Cable Tv A Dream For A Sports Fanatic
Free Fox Sports Live Online Tv Streams On Your ComFree Soccer Training Drills Tips On Creating Space
Free Watch Sky Sports Live Tv OnlineGermany National Football Team
Get A Soccer Jersey To Show Your Team LoyaltyGet A Stylish Look With Sports Sunglasses
Getting Your Sports Memorabilia AppraisedGlycerol The Practical Answer To Dehydration In Th
Groomsmen Gift Ideas For Sports FanaticsHigh School Football Coach Transforms Program Into
History Of Jordan Basketball Shorts And BrandHow Make Money As A Sports Ticket Broker
How Sports Can Relieve StressHow To Effectively Break Down A Basketball Game Fi
How To Get Cheap Football JerseysHow To Give A Good Sports Massage
How To Know If Your Basketball Shoes Are Genuine OHow To Master The 3 Most Important Soccer Moves
How To Start Collecting Sports Memorabilia Like KeHow To Teach Aggressive Soccer Play
How To Use Coerver Coaching To Improve Soccer PlayHow To Watch Football Live Satellite Tv On Pc Revi
How To Write A Sports ProposalI Love Aau Basketball
Important Of Basketball UniformsImprove Your Soccer Stamina With Some Simple Exerc
Increase Your Vertical Leap And Dunk A BasketballIntegrating Football Into Organizational Structure
Is The 53 A Good Defense For Youth FootballJoomla Sports Website
Kobe Shoes Are The Fans Of The Wellknown BasketbalLeading Manufacturer And Supplier Of Football Or S
Learn Best Way To Watch Streaming Live Nfl FootbalLearn How To Play Box Lacrosse
Legendary Football StadiumsLooking For The Best Basketball Shoes For Me
Lyrics That Psyche Up Sports FansMidget Football Teaching Set Pattern Blocking
Missed Calls By The Basketball RefereeMy Favorite Sports Is Mountain Biking
New Messi Football Shoes The Latest In The FashionNews Writing I How To Write A Sports Report In 4 S
Nfl Authentic Football JerseysNfl Jerseys Nfl Sports Apparel The Fashion For The
Nike Air Jordan Footwear A EffectivelyacknowledgedNike Ctr360 Soccer Unique Design
Nike Football BootsNike Shoes To Help Improve Sports Performance
Nike Shoesthe Best Shoes In The Sports WorldNikeexcellent Sports Shoes
Notre Dame Football Weekend Rental Rent Like A ChaNumerous Original Nba Basketball Jerseys Clearly S
Optimal Hypertrophy For Sports Supertraining ExtraOur Nike Air Max Our Football Team
Paid Soccer Coaches Worth The CostParis Massage Domicile And The Treatment Of Sports
Perfectly Designed Soccer Shoes Like Nike And AdidPermanent Basketball Goals I The Facts On Getting
Picking The Proper Soccer ShoesPoland Vs. Peru In Argentina 78 A Ladys Football M
Polyester Is The King Of Soccer UniformsPower And High Quality Of Nike Dunks Make Them Fin
Preparing Your Body To Play FootballPrescription Safety Glasses For Sports Enthusiasts
Primary Research Into A Sports Business OrganisatiPrivacy
Proper Care Guide For Your Football Team KitsPublic Relations Sports Endorsements Gone Bad
Re Sports Inc Coupons Re Sports Inc Coupon CodesReviewing The Peewee Football Playbook
Rl Sports And StylesRonaldinho Is Wellknown As One Of The Worldis Most
School In Puebla Football Club Fc Barcelona Camp NSetting Up A Junior Football Team
Six Basketball Defense Tips Defending The BasketbaSoccer A Numberis Game
Soccer Conditioning Killer Tips On Postmatch RecovSoccer Corner Adidas F50 Adizero Adidas Adizerof50
Soccer EquipmentSoccer Field Diagram 3 Ways To Learn Soccer Positi
Soccer Field Diagram How To Decide Soccer PositionSoccer Field Positions
Soccer Game And Your Daily HealthSoccer Is One Of The Most Competitive Sports In Th
Soccer JerseySoccer Nicknames
Soccer Number 10 Skillest Of The SkillSoccer Practices Uses Too Much Repetition
Soccer Shoes Prefect Your Performance In Football Spanish Football History
Sport Psychology Monitor Your Control Panel DuringSports Apparel The New And Improved Fashions For S
Sports Channels A Brief History Of Sports BroadcasSports Cupping I How Itis Beneficial
Sports Facilities At Oberoi International SchoolSports Facilities For Schools And Sports Centres
Sports Jerseys SymbolsSports Psychology For The Winning Edge
Sports Sunglasses Wear The Right Shades With Your Sports Trivia Questions Truly Awesome Athletes
Strength Speed And Agility The Keys In SoccerStress And Burnout In Youth Sports
Swinton Travel Insurance Insuring The Hopes And DrTeach You Watch Live Football Games Online Through
Teaching Wedge Blocking For Youth FootballTechniques For Racing A Sports Car
The 8 Best Defensive Coverages In FootballThe Art Of Basketball Shooting Discovered
The Base 53 Defense For Youth Football.The Benefits Of Negative Ion Sports Bracelets
The Benefits Of Sports ActivitiesThe Best Right Midfielders Ever To Play Soccer
The Best Soccer Cleats And Football Boots At CleatThe Best Soccer Moves In The Drunken Masters Drunk
The Effects Of Wwe And Its Marketing On The Rest OThe Importance Of Good Signals To A Basketball Ref
The Importance Of Passing Correctly In BasketballThe Leather Football Shoe Or The Man Made Leather
The Most Popular Sports ShoesThe Natural Leather Soccer Boot Compared To The Sy
The Price Strategy Of International Sports BrandsThe Single Wing Offense To Win Big In Youth Footba
The Top 5 Best And Worst Football Grounds In EnglaThe Way To Display Sports Shirts In Jersey Display
Things You Can Do With A Soccer BallThings You Should Be Aware Of If You Wish To Slam
Tips For Earning College Soccer ScholarshipsTips For Maintenance Basketball Shoes
Toddler Indoor Soccer ShoesUltimate Adidas Sneakers Is A Comfortable Sports F
Uncovering The Perfect Sports Watch Every Runner MUnderstanding Different Sports Massage Sequence
Understanding The Meaning Of Duotones In Digital SUniqueness Of Sports Headphones
Using Kids Sports To Encourage TeamworkUsing Powerball For Sports Exercise
Want To Watch Soccer Online Check Out These 3 AwesWatch Free Live Espn Sky Sports Tv Streaming On Pc
Watch Live Football On Your Pc For FreeWatch Live Nfl Streaming Online Football On Fox Cb
Watch Live Premier League Soccer On Your Laptop OrWatch Live Sports Espn Starsports Sky Sports Nfl F
Watch Nfl Football Game Online On Pc Tv Watch Tv OWater Sports In Malta
Ways To Watch Espn Live Football And Fifa World CuWearing Nike Air Max To Perfect Your Sports Perfor
Weird And Wonderful SportsWhat Do Soccer Uniforms Look Like
What Is The Best Offensive Line Blocking Scheme FoWhat Is The Point In Football Tips
What Professional Football Jerseys The Most PopulaWhat To Choose For Soccer Cleats
What Youll Want To Find Out About Basketball GoalsWhen Soccer Came To Brazil
Where Should I Put My Best Players On Defense CoacWhich Sports Balm Is Right For You
Who Invented FootballWholesale Sports Clothing The Best In Outdoor Wear
Why Black Football Shirts Outsell Other ColoursWhy It Is Critical To Use The Right Sports Sunglas
Why Soccer Is My Favorite SportWhy Sports Apparel Is Growing
Why Sports Massage And Basketball Go Hand In HandWhy We Need To Get Soccer Jersey Earlier
Win The Football Pools Do Systems Really WorkWorld Soccer League Exciting Virtual Soccer Game
Your Sports Gear Must Represent Your ProfessionaliYouth Brazilian Soccer Training Video Speed Traini